HOME|News|Canada AM|W5|Weather|Video|Sports|Entertainment|Programs|TV Listing|Autos|Contests
CTV Winnipeg
Andrea and Ginette Markowski

Andrea and Ginette Markowski

Andrea and Ginette Markowski say it was a doctor in this clinic that refused them treatment

Andrea and Ginette Markowski say it was a doctor in this clinic that refused them treatment

Same-sex couple complains about Winnipeg doctor

Updated: Tue Jan. 27 2009 18:24:42

ctvwinnipeg.ca

A Winnipeg couple is searching for a new doctor, after their first visit with one doctor was also their last.

The same sex couple feels they were denied treatment, because of their sexual orientation.

"We weren't braced for a potential problem, because we've never had a problem with a doctor," explains Andrea Markowski.

Markowski and her partner say they had a problem with Doctor Kamelia Elias who works at a Winnipeg clinic.

Markowski says it really was the other way around saying the doctor had a problem with them.

"I directly asked her if our sexual orientation was causing a problem for her in terms of her ability to care for us, and she said yes," said Markowski.

Doctor Elias commented only through her attorney who tells CTV News that the doctor feels this has been a misunderstanding, and blown out of proportion.

Doctor Elias says she never refused to treat the couple. Instead she was only sharing information about her religious beliefs and inexperience in treating homosexual patients.

The director of the medical clinic says the doctor lacked exposure to homosexual patients in her previous practices in Egypt and Steinbach.

University of Manitoba Ethics professor Arthur Schafer says doctors cannot refuse to treat patients because they disagree with the patients' lifestyle.

"If the evidence shows this doctor, whatever reason she gave, was discriminating on the grounds of sexual orientation then she should be disciplined," says Schafer.

Andrea and Ginette Markowski say they've filed a complaint with the Manitoba Human Rights Commission and the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Manitoba.

Doctor Bill Pope from the College of Physicians and Surgeons says the matter must be investigated fully, but says it may be that doctors, especially foreign trained doctors, need more education before practicing in Manitoba. That is something Andrea Markowski would support.

With a report from CTV's Jon Hendricks

CTV NEWS VIDEO PLAYER
Viewer
CTV's Jon Hendricks on charges of gender discrimination

User Tools

Advertisement

What's On
Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon
Toronto Thu, Feb 9, 12
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
9:30pm
Up All Night
10:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
7:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
7:30pm
Up All Night
8:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
9:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
7:30pm
Up All Night
8:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
9:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
9:30pm
Up All Night
10:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
9:30pm
Up All Night
10:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
8:00pm
The Big Bang Theory
8:30pm
Up All Night
9:00pm
Grey's Anatomy
10:00pm
The Mentalist
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Wed, Feb 8, 12
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
Blue Bloods
9:00pm
CSI: NY
10:00pm
Grimm
7:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Grimm
9:00pm
Blue Bloods
7:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Grimm
9:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
Blue Bloods
9:00pm
CSI: NY
10:00pm
Grimm
8:00pm
Blue Bloods
9:00pm
CSI: NY
10:00pm
Grimm
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Grimm
10:00pm
Blue Bloods
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Tue, Feb 7, 12
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
7:00pm
The Voice
9:00pm
Smash
10:00pm
W5
7:00pm
The Voice
9:00pm
Smash
10:00pm
W5
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Mon, Feb 6, 12
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Pan Am
9:00pm
Once Upon a Time
10:00pm
Desperate Housewives
7:00pm
Once Upon a Time
8:00pm
Desperate Housewives
9:00pm
Pan Am
10:00pm
Whitney
10:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
7:00pm
Once Upon a Time
8:00pm
Desperate Housewives
9:00pm
Pan Am
10:00pm
Whitney
10:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Pan Am
9:00pm
Once Upon a Time
10:00pm
Desperate Housewives
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Pan Am
9:00pm
Once Upon a Time
10:00pm
Desperate Housewives
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
7:00pm
Whitney
7:30pm
Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm
Once Upon a Time
9:00pm
Desperate Housewives
10:00pm
Pan Am
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Sun, Feb 5, 12
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
7:00pm
The Voice
9:00pm
Smash
7:00pm
The Voice
9:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
8:00pm
Smash
9:00pm
The Voice
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
8:00pm
The Voice
10:00pm
Smash
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am
Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize


Poll Question